The Click Trap: How Companies Are Misleading Consumers Into Subscriptions

It starts innocently enough: a discounted product, a tempting free trial, or a seamless one-click checkout. But beneath the convenience lies a growing issue—subscription traps. These are schemes where companies enrol consumers into recurring payments—often without clear consent or adequate disclosure.

A subscription is a contract—a legally binding agreement for a regular fee. However, many people only realise they’re subscribed when unexpected charges appear on their bank statements—charges that are vague, difficult to trace, and even harder to cancel.

 

What Are Subscription Traps?

Subscription traps are deceptive marketing tactics that lock consumers into ongoing payments. These often involve:

  • Pre-ticked boxes hidden in the fine print
  • Ambiguous language like “Join & Save” or “Free Trial”
  • Hard-to-find cancellation options
  • Unclear or undisclosed pricing for future charges
  • Pop-ups or redirects that may not be linked to the original service

 

UK Law: Your Rights as a Consumer

Under UK consumer protection law, including the Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013 and the Consumer Rights Act 2015, businesses must:

  • Obtain clear, express consent before charging
  • Disclose all fees and terms upfront
  • Provide a simple and accessible cancellation method

If they fail to comply, they risk legal action and reputational damage.

๐Ÿ“Œ Important: Failing to provide transparent subscription terms may constitute an unfair commercial practice under UK law.

 

Beware of Fake Cancellation Services

Another growing issue is third-party websites offering to cancel subscriptions on your behalf—for a fee. These companies may claim to send a termination letter, only to charge you later for a service that you may have already completed yourself.

๐Ÿšซ These are often unregulated, use hidden fees, and rely on unclear consent. In many cases, consumers report being invoiced unexpectedly, after assuming the service was free or already resolved.

 

CMA Enforcement

The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) has taken action against multiple brands using misleading subscription models. Outcomes include:

  • Public warnings
  • Fines and legal action
  • Enforced updates to cancellation policies
  • Guidance to ensure fair practices in the subscription economy

 

How to Protect Yourself as a Consumer

To avoid falling victim to subscription traps:

๐Ÿ•’ Don’t rush purchases—ignore countdown timers urging you to “act fast”

๐Ÿ” Watch for phrases like “Subscribe & Save”, “Trial”, or “Exclusive Access”

๐Ÿงพ Monitor your bank or credit card statements regularly

๐Ÿ“ฌ Be cautious of third-party cancellation services

๐Ÿ› ๏ธ Use free tools like Resolver or the CMA complaints hub if you feel misled

 

Best Practices for Businesses

To stay compliant and protect your brand:

โœ๏ธ Use clear, honest language in all checkout and subscription flows

๐Ÿ’ธ Disclose all recurring charges upfront

๐Ÿ“ฅ Ensure users opt-in manually (no pre-ticked boxes)

โŒ Offer frictionless cancellation options via a customer portal or email

๐Ÿ”’ Align with GDPR, UK consumer law, and digital marketing regulations

 

Build Trust with Transparent Contracts

At GR Ace Legal Compliance, I can help consumers protect their rights and guide businesses to create compliant, ethical subscription models that foster long-term trust—not legal issues. 

Let’s work together to eliminate deceptive practices and build better digital experiences.

Get in touch with your story or experience at www.gracelegal.net or DM me at @grace.legal2025 or contact me via info@gracelegal.net.